Building the Desk
The Amazon plan that never filled, and the SPCX levels we drew but did not trade
Two fresh paper results from this week: a plan whose direction was right but whose entry was too deep, and a skipped short with a very specific map of price levels.
Two things happened on the Desk this week that are worth writing down while they are fresh. One paper trade plan never got in, even though the stock went where we thought it would. And one plan idea in SPCX was skipped, but the price levels we drew for it turned out to be a useful map. Both are small, honest lessons about what separates a good idea from a plan that works.
DePappa Capital trades only its own capital. Nothing here is investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer of any kind. Everything below is paper research, which means no real money was at risk and no real return was earned.
The Amazon plan that never filled
On Friday, October 30, the Desk's Chief built a paper long in Amazon (AMZN), and it was approved at 5:48 PM ET. It had four numbers. The entry was 237.75. The stop, the price where we would admit we were wrong, was 232.90. The first partial target was 243.70 and the full target was 246.90. The size was 51 shares, set so that a stop-out would cost about $250. The plan was good through the 4 PM ET close on Monday, November 2.
It did not fill. When the Desk was read back after the close, the plan showed no entry, no exit and no profit or loss. That is the whole result. We did not win and we did not lose. The plan simply never started.
The reason is easy to see in the price. The Desk's last market read on Monday, at 3:30 PM ET, had Amazon at 247.108. That is above our 246.90 target. So the stock did what the idea expected and then some, but our order was waiting at 237.75, well below where the stock was trading, and it never got in. The direction was right. The limit was too deep.
That is a different kind of miss than a stopped-out trade, and it is worth naming on its own. A plan can fail because the idea was wrong. It can also fail because the entry asked the market for a price it never offered. The second kind never shows up as a loss, which makes it easy to ignore, but it still means a good idea earned nothing.
Reading the Amazon plan the other way is just as important. Because nothing filled, there is no result to celebrate or to blame. We are not counting this plan as a win because the stock reached the target, and we are not counting it as a loss. It is a plan that ran out its time without a trade, and that is how it is scored.
The SPCX levels we drew and did not trade
The second story is about a plan we never saved. On October 30, gamma levels for SPCX came in from TerraShade. Gamma levels are price points drawn from where options traders are positioned. They are context, not instructions.
Four details framed the picture. The put wall, a level traders often watch as a floor, was 135. The call wall, often watched as a ceiling, was 150. The gamma flip, roughly where the way options dealers hedge is thought to change, was 144.33. And the stock was in negative gamma, a condition where dealer hedging is thought to push price moves further instead of calming them, which can make a stock jumpier.
The plan on the table was a paper short. The entry was 140, the stop was 145.30, the first target was 136 and the full target was 128. The stop sat just above the flip at 144.33, so the plan would be wrong if price climbed through it. The first target sat just above the 135 put wall.
That short was skipped after the Desk rejected the save, so it never became a live plan. SPCX closed at 134.72, just under the 135 put wall. We are not claiming the short would have made money. We do not have a fill or an outcome for it, and a plan that was never saved has no score. What the levels show is that the map was specific. Every number had a place on it, and the close landed right next to one of those numbers.
What the two have in common
Both stories come back to the same point. A plan is only useful if every price in it is reachable and tied to something you can see. The SPCX short had a clear reason behind each level, and it still did not become a trade. The Amazon plan was approved and still never filled, because its entry was set where the market never went.
The lesson is a question to ask of any plan before it is approved. If the idea is right, will the market actually offer this entry?
Every post and article on this journal, including this one, still needs Michael's approval before it goes out.